Wiki / United Kingdom / Family Wealth: Matrimonial Property, Inheritance and Governance

Companies & fundsWealth planning

Family Wealth: Matrimonial Property, Inheritance and Governance

share
LinkedIne-mail
mdmcp

Family capital does not break where an unlucky jurisdiction was chosen; it breaks where the order was muddled. There are three layers: the matrimonial property regime, the instrument of ownership, and the event everything was built for. They work in one order only — first establish what the owner is entitled to dispose of, then choose the construction, and only then plan for divorce, death or the change of generation. Getting the order wrong costs more than any rate of tax, because it is put right not by a document but by litigation.

There are exactly two standard mistakes, and both are inversions. The first: a trust or a personal fund is filled out of the common matrimonial pot without anyone asking about the regime. The structure changes title, but it does not answer the question whose money went into it: assets transferred without the spouse's consent, or on the eve of a crisis, come back into the division through clawback mechanisms in almost every jurisdiction. The second: the marital agreement is drafted after the holding has been assembled and the shares distributed — at which point the agreement stops being a plan and becomes a reaction, and an asymmetric agreement signed against a background of debt or of pre-divorce correspondence is examined by the courts as a suspicious transaction.

This map connects four questions — regime, instrument, event and governance — and directs the reader to the specialist studies. Its own task is coordination: how matrimonial arrangements, succession instruments and the choice of law fit together. The national rules for contractual waivers are explained in the reserved-share study.

A family's migration status settles the children's position as much as the adults' right to be present: it governs the tuition rate a child pays, the pool a child competes in for admission, and the clock on which citizenship arrives. Those entitlements are covered in What a Status Is Worth Beyond Entry: Tuition, Admission and a Child's Citizenship; the status axis in full is the migration domain map.

Section map: which question to start from and where the answer is.

Reader's questionPage
What counts as common property — and under which law?Matrimonial property regimes
How is the regime fixed by agreement when assets sit in several countries?Cross-border prenuptial agreements
Trust or private foundation — which construction fits the family?How a trust works · Private foundations
Which court will hear the divorce?Cross-border divorce jurisdiction
Will the structure survive the division of property?Division of property in an international divorce
What has to be in the succession plan?Succession planning
Which law will govern the succession?The law applicable to succession
How much will the reserved share take?The reserved share and forced heirship
What will the transfer of capital to the heirs cost?The inheritance tax map
Is it time for an in-house family office?The family office
Where will a child be able to study, and at which fee rate?What a status is worth beyond entry
Which citizenship will a child acquire, and on what clock?What a status is worth beyond entry
Which international school, in which city, at what published fee?International schools
Which health cover will the residence permit accept?International health insurance

Layer 1. The regime: what the owner is entitled to dispose of

Every couple has a property regime: if the spouses chose nothing, the conflict-of-laws rules chose for them. The world divides into three families — community of acquests (France, Spain, Italy, Latin America, Russia), separation of property (England, Austria) and equalisation of accrued gains (Germany, Switzerland, Scandinavia). The difference is not cosmetic: the German Zugewinnausgleich gives a monetary claim for half the difference between the accruals rather than a share in particular assets, and for a business owner that is a fundamentally different outcome from the French communauté.

The second storey is which law governs that regime. In the EU the conflicts layer is unified by Regulation 2016/1103, applicable from 29 January 2019 in 18 Member States: the spouses may choose the law of the habitual residence or of the nationality of either of them (Art. 22); absent a choice the cascade in Art. 26 operates, and the applicable law does not change on a move. Outside that perimeter the logic can run the other way: under Art. 55 of the Swiss Private International Law Act a transfer of domicile switches on the law of the new place of residence retroactively, as at the date of the marriage, unless the spouses have excluded retroactivity in writing.

The Russian circuit adds a creditor layer that people remember too late. Under Art. 46 of the Russian Family Code a spouse must notify creditors of the conclusion, amendment or termination of a marital agreement, and on failure to do so is liable on his obligations irrespective of the content of the agreement: an unnotified creditor is entitled to ignore it. In bankruptcy the spouses' common property falls into the estate and is sold as a whole, the share being paid out of the proceeds (Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 48 of 25.12.2018), while the agreement itself is challenged as a suspicious transaction under Art. 61.2 of the Bankruptcy Law.

Layer 2. The instrument: title on one side, control on the other

The instrument is chosen after the regime and before the event. Its task is to separate title from benefit so that the construction outlives the owner and does not fall apart at the change of generation. The continental family more often takes a foundation, the common-law family a trust, the Russian one a personal fund; a separate fork is who manages it — a professional trustee or the family's own private trust company.

The limit of the instrument is set by two English cases analysed in the study of the division of property: Charman v Charman [2007] EWCA Civ 503, where the assets of a discretionary trust entered the calculation as a financial resource under s. 25(2)(a) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, and Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd [2013] UKSC 34, where the properties held by the husband's companies went to the wife not through piercing the corporate veil but through a resulting trust. The design lesson is a single one: a structure is tested not for legality but against the question "and what if he asks?".

Layer 3. The event: death and divorce

The event is the last layer, and that is precisely why it is not planned first. On death the sequence has two steps: the pot is first divided under the matrimonial property regime and the survivor's share taken out, and only the remainder becomes the estate. The two governing laws are determined by different connecting factors and may perfectly well point to different legal systems — the German § 1371 BGB, which replaces equalisation of accruals with a flat increase of the statutory share by a quarter of the estate, is classified by a foreign court now as a rule of the property regime, now as a rule of succession, and the price of that classification runs to tens of per cent of the estate.

The seam: the contractual waiver of the reserved share

Exactly on the joint between the marriage axis and the death axis sits an instrument that is neither a marital agreement nor a will — the inter vivos contractual waiver of the reserved share. It solves a problem no single layer solves on its own: removing a future reserved heir's claim before the succession opens, and doing so by agreement rather than by unilateral disposition. Continental systems allow it to differing degrees; the Russian one does not allow it at all.

Germany. The law distinguishes a waiver of statutory succession from a waiver limited to the reserved share. Under the full waiver, the person is treated as though they had not survived the opening of succession; the narrower version leaves intestate succession untouched. The formalities and cancellation rules belong to the reserved-share study; the family plan must coordinate that choice with its matrimonial arrangements.

France. The RAAR is an advance waiver of the action to reduce gifts; it binds only once accepted by the future testator. The reserved-share study explains its statutory conditions and scope.

For the family settlement, identify the beneficiary by name; the beneficiary need not be an heir. The separate authentic deed and signing formalities are explained in the French waiver rules.

Under Art. 930-1 of the French Civil Code such a waiver is not a gratuitous disposition, and so is not taxed as a gift.

Russia: not removable by contract. The reserved share under Art. 1149 of the Russian Civil Code — not less than half of what would have fallen due on intestacy — cannot be given up in advance either by a marital agreement or by an inheritance contract. Art. 1140.1 of the Russian Civil Code says so directly: the terms of an inheritance contract operate only so far as they do not conflict with the rules on the reserved share, and when a reserved heir appears the contracting heir's obligations are reduced in proportion to what goes into the reserved share. The inheritance contract and the joint will of spouses were introduced by Federal Law No. 217-FZ of 19.07.2018, which amended both Art. 256 of Part One and Part Three of the Civil Code — but they take the reserved share as a given, not as the subject of a bargain.

The second risk at the seam is a conflicts risk. A waiver removes the reserved share given by the law applicable to the succession, and that law is not determined by where the contract was signed. Within the perimeter of Regulation 650/2012 the succession is governed by the deceased's last habitual residence or by a professio juris in favour of the law of nationality, whereas the matrimonial regime follows its own connecting factor under Regulation 2016/1103. A German Pflichtteilsverzicht signed by a family that then settles in France without a choice of law risks meeting a reserve other than the one waived; a French RAAR in favour of a named donee does not carry over to assets that fall under a different succession law. Hence the rule: the waiver is signed in one package with a choice of law on both axes — succession and matrimonial — and not as a free-standing document.

Layer 4. Governance: the office, the rules and the next generation

The fourth layer answers the question of who runs all of this once the regime has been fixed, the instrument assembled and the event planned. A family office is not a tax construction but an operating circuit: consolidated reporting, an investment strategy, a calendar of obligations across every family entity, and the preparation of the heirs. An in-house SFO is usually justified at capital of roughly US$100–250m and costs from US$1–2m a year; below that mark the same function is covered by the service model.

TaskWhat to readKey figure or rule
Establish what the owner is entitled to dispose ofMatrimonial property regimesthree families of regime; in the EU the applicable law comes from Regulation 2016/1103, from 29.01.2019 in 18 Member States, and does not change on a move
Check the regime after a moveMatrimonial property regimesArt. 55 of the Swiss PILA: the law of the new domicile applies retroactively as at the date of the marriage unless retroactivity is excluded in writing
Fix the regime by agreementCross-border prenuptial agreementschoice of law under Art. 22 of Regulation 2016/1103 — residence or nationality of one of the spouses only; in Russia the filter is the proviso in Art. 44 of the Family Code
Keep the agreement good against creditorsMatrimonial property regimesArt. 46 of the Russian Family Code: without notice to the creditor the spouse is liable irrespective of the content of the agreement; Plenum of the Supreme Court No. 48 of 25.12.2018 on the bankruptcy circuit
Assess whether the structure survives a divorceDivision of property in an international divorceCharman [2007] EWCA Civ 503 — trust assets as a financial resource under s. 25(2)(a) MCA 1973; Prest [2013] UKSC 34 — a resulting trust instead of piercing the veil
Choose the instrument of ownershipTrusts · Private foundationsthe common law / continental fork; control inside the family through a PTC
Understand the order on the death of a spouseSuccession planningthe matrimonial share first, then the estate; § 1371 BGB replaces equalisation of accruals by raising the statutory share by a quarter of the estate
Identify the law governing the successionThe law applicable to successionRegulation 650/2012 from 17.08.2015 across the EU except Denmark and Ireland; professio juris in favour of the law of nationality
Calculate the reserved shareThe reserved share and forced heirshipArt. 1149 of the Russian Civil Code — not less than half the statutory share; the French réserve of 1/2, 2/3 and 3/4; the German Pflichtteil — half the statutory share
Remove the reserved share by contract in GermanyThe reserved share and forced heirship§ 2346 Abs. 2 BGB — the waiver may be limited to the right to the reserved share; § 2348 — notarial form; § 2347 — the testator concludes the contract in person; § 2351 — cancellation by a counter-contract
Remove the reserved share by contract in FranceThe reserved share and forced heirshipArt. 929 of the French Civil Code (Law No. 2006-728 of 23.06.2006): the waiver binds from the day the future testator accepts it; Art. 930 — a separate deed before two notaries; Art. 930-1 — not a gift
Check whether a waiver works in RussiaThe reserved share and forced heirshipArt. 1140.1 of the Russian Civil Code: an inheritance contract operates only so far as it does not conflict with the rules on the reserved share; the obligations are reduced proportionately
Cost the tax on the eventThe inheritance tax map · US estate taxa US non-resident gets an exemption of $60,000 on US-situs assets and a rate of up to 40%, and the threshold is not indexed
Rebuild a trust for the British reformTrusts and UK IHTfrom 06.04.2025 IHT is tied to long-term residence: worldwide assets after 10 of the last 20 tax years, with a tail of 3–10 years after departure
Work out when an in-house office is neededThe family office · The economics of a family officea benchmark of US$100–250m of capital and US$1–2m of annual budget; below that, the service model
Choose the jurisdiction for the officeDIFC · Hong Kong FIHV · SingaporeDIFC — about $50m of net assets; FIHV — HK$240m, 2 FTE and HK$2m of opex; Singapore 13O — S$20m, 13U — S$50m, the schemes running to 31.12.2029
Write down the rules for those marrying inThe family charterthe charter provision is converted into a marital agreement with a choice of law: Reg. (EU) 2016/1103 Arts. 22, 23, 25, 26; § 1410 BGB; Art. 42 of the Russian Family Code

The relocating family: school, health cover, status

A family that moves carries three running costs the four layers do not price: the school, the health cover the permit demands, and the entitlements the status does or does not open. Each has a comparative owner, and the figures below are the published ones those pages rely on.

QuestionWhere the matrix sitsA published figure to anchor it
What a premium international school costs, city by cityInternational schools2026/27 secondary tuition: Dubai College AED 97,415–110,305, UWCSEA S$47,313–49,926, Ecolint CHF 35,290–36,540, ZIS CHF 39,300–39,700, Westminster day £49,368–52,446 with 20% VAT since 1 January 2025
Which health cover a residence programme accepts, and when the public system opensInternational health insuranceSpain: insurer authorised in Spain, then the special agreement at €60 or €157 a month after a year; Italy: at least €2,000 a year for voluntary SSN enrolment; UK surcharge £1,035 a year
Which permit gives the domestic tuition rate and public health coverWhat a status is worth beyond entryEngland: settlement plus three years; France: two years in a French tax household; Portugal: more than two years' residence on 1 January
How long from permit to passport, and what breaks the pathThe life cycle of a migration statussix months abroad ends a German permit; ILR lapses after two years out; Canada counts 1,095 days in five years

The order of the four layers still holds inside a move: the school and the permit are fixed first because they set where the family is resident, and habitual residence in turn decides the default succession law under Regulation 650/2012 and, in systems such as the Swiss one, can move the matrimonial regime as well.

Q/A

Where to begin if the structure has not yet been built

With an audit of the matrimonial regime, not with the choice of a trust. The question "which law governs our regime, and from what date" is answered by the conflict-of-laws rules of the country of residence, and the answer determines what the owner may dispose of alone. Only after that does it make sense to compare instruments: assets transferred into a structure out of the common pot without the spouse's consent come back into the division. The order is set out in matrimonial property regimes and cross-border prenuptial agreements.

Does a trust protect against the reserved share and against division on divorce

Against the reserved share — not always: France and Italy apply clawback, bringing lifetime gifts and contributions to trusts back into the calculation of the reserve, while offshore firewall provisions answer that by cutting off foreign succession claims; the outcome depends on where the assets sit and where the litigation has to happen. Against divorce — the less so the closer the structure stands to the marriage: an English court treats the assets of a discretionary trust as a resource of the spouse and may vary the terms of a trust classified as a nuptial settlement. The studies: the reserved share, division of property, asset protection trusts.

Can the reserved share be waived in advance

The answer depends on the succession law: Germany and France provide distinct contractual mechanisms, while Russia does not let an inheritance contract override the reserved share. The country rules and formalities are set out in the specialist study. Here the planning task is to coordinate any valid waiver with the matrimonial arrangements and both choices of applicable law.

Why the waiver is signed together with a choice of law

Because the waiver removes the reserved share given by the applicable succession law, and that law is determined separately from the place of signature. In the EU the succession is governed by Regulation 650/2012 — the last habitual residence or a professio juris — while the matrimonial regime follows the connecting factor in Regulation 2016/1103. A family that signs a waiver in one country and settles in another without a choice of law risks ending up with a reserve it never waived. The mechanics of the two governing laws are in the law applicable to succession.

What happens to the pot on the death of a spouse

It is divided twice. The matrimonial property regime operates first and the survivor's share is taken out, and only the remainder becomes the estate distributed under the succession law. The two governing laws are determined by different connecting factors and may perfectly well point to different legal systems; the classic knot is § 1371 BGB, which replaces equalisation of accruals with a flat increase of the survivor's statutory share by a quarter of the estate, and the question whether a foreign court assigns that rule to the property regime or to succession. The reserved share is calculated only after the matrimonial share — see succession planning.

When a family needs its own family office

When the capital and the number of structures outweigh the cost of a permanent team: the practical benchmark is US$100–250m, with a budget from US$1–2m a year, and on $100m such a budget already amounts to roughly 100 bps. Below that mark the function is covered by the service model: a single point of entry, an entity administrator and a personal adviser. The jurisdiction is chosen by the principals' residence and banking access, not by the headline rate: DIFC, Hong Kong, Singapore, Switzerland. The economics of the layer are in the economics of a family office.

Discuss “Family Wealth: Matrimonial Property, Inheritance and Governance”

Maria Plotnikova
Author of the materialMaria PlotnikovaLawyer, Family Office

Your question about “Family Wealth: Matrimonial Property, Inheritance and Governance”

We’ll reply to the email address you provide.

Your contacts are used to answer this request. No mailing lists.